‘Do you know what it is?’: Minister fumbles over Return and Earn detail
NSW Environment Minister Gabrielle Upton has dodged questions from Ben Fordham over a crucial Return and Earn detail.
Ms Upton insists the container deposit scheme is now “steady” and going “real places” but can’t give a figure on how many containers are going through the vending machines as a percentage of how many containers are sold.
“There are almost 640 million drink containers through the system since it began,” the Minister says.
Ben, “Does that work out to be 10 per cent of the total number of containers that are sold? Or 25 per cent or 50 per cent?”
Minister Upton, “Look, it is a percentage of the drink containers that are sold. Not every drink container, Ben, is going to be put through the system. People are making a choice.”
Ben, “But what is it? 50 per cent? Do you know what it is?”
Despite not being able to answer the question, Ms Upton says the figure wouldn’t determine “whether this scheme is a success”.
“There are many millions of drinks that are eligible to be returned, sold every day,” she says.
“People make choices about whether they will claim back a deposit.
“The strong numbers, just under 640 million drink containers, indicates that lots and lots of people every day are returning it and participating in the scheme.”
Click PLAY below to hear the fiery interview
Ben has since crunched the numbers, and has the figures.
“The return rate is 27 per cent,” he says. “So out of 100 containers sold, 27 are handed in on average.
“So if 640 million have been handed in in total, the total number of containers sold since December 1, would be approximately 2.3 billion.”
Click PLAY below to hear Ben’s update