arrowMake 2GB Your Home Page  |  Support  |  Search  |  Contact Us
 
   
 
MON - FRI 5am to 5.30am MON - FRI 5.30am to 9am TUE - THU 8pm to 9pm

Big business driving small business out of business

Print E-mail

The more dominant Woolworths and Coles become in the market, the faster the prices accelerate.

 

Well, it goes on and on.

And no change in Government appears as if it's going to make any difference.

The Federal Government have given people 900 dollars here, 2000 dollars there.

Some people before Christmas got cheques of 10,000 dollars.

A lot of it went in grog.

Figures from the Bureau of Statistics show that retail sales in liquor stores surged a massive 14 per cent over the Christmas period compared to last year.

And in the month of January this year, as compared to January last year, expenditure on liquor increased by over 100 million dollars around the nation.

That is a 100 million dollar increase in expenditure on liquor in the month of January alone.

So, this should be a great time to be in the liquor retail business.

But 13 bottle shops in New South Wales last week trading under the Liquor Legends banner shut up shop, owing Westpac 10 million dollars.

In other words, small businesses being driven out of business and their staff sent into unemployment queues.

Those people who wish to continue to stick their head in the sand about what I call the Woolworths effect will claim that this is just part of the economic climate and the downturn in the market.

There is no downturn in the market when it comes to liquor sales.

A 100 million dollar increase in liquor expenditure in the month of January compared to January last year.

Yet 13 independent bottle shops driven to ruin and bankruptcy.

The reason is simple.

The failure of the Trade Practices Act, which allows the evil of anti-competitive price discrimination, a practice whereby small businesses are unfairly discriminated against and forced to pay higher prices for their goods without any economic justification.

So what's happening every day around the nation is a truck loads up from a brewery and delivers a pallet of beer to a Woolworths liquor outlet.

The same truck then delivers the same quantity of the same beer to an independent liquor outlet across the road, but the independent pays up to 25 per cent more.

And this economic absurdity is played out around the nation.

Independents are discriminated against to such an extent by the breweries that they are paying a higher price for their beer than what Woolworths and Coles are retailing it for.

But here we've got a Competition and Consumer Commission, we've got a government, we've got political promises and nothing happens.

In the past four years Woolworths and Coles have increased their market share in liquor retailing from 32 per cent to 52 per cent.

Just by eliminating the competition with anti-competitive practices that are illegal in the majority of developed countries.

Of course the apologists say this is vigorous competition, that Woolworths and Coles are just being highly competitive.

This is voodoo economics.

A myth that is swallowed hook, line and sinker by governments across the country who are frightened of offending big business, and by media outlets who of course rely on significant income streams from Woolworths and Coles, witness the full page advertisements taken out by Woolworths and Coles or their subsidiaries in newspapers every other day.

The statistics tell the story.

Since the year 2000 the CPI has increased by 32 per cent.

Prices generally have increased by 32 per cent.

But in liquor, where Woolworths and Coles have supposedly increased competition, since the year 2000 the price of spirits has jumped by 50 per cent and beer prices have gone up by 53 per cent.

In other words, the price of all goods goes up 32 per cent.

But where Woolworths and Coles have increased their dominance in liquor retailing, the price of spirits has increased by 50 per cent and the price of beer by 53 per cent.

Just like in groceries, the more dominant Woolworths and Coles become in the market, the faster the prices accelerate, damaging the national economy and undermining economic prosperity.

A fact completely lost on those in Canberra.

So it's jobs, jobs, jobs, is it.

Tell that to the workers in 13 liquor stores in New South Wales who have shut up shop this month.

Government stands by and does nothing.

 

Comments

2009-04-22 20:48:15

Exactly what happened here yrs. ago-bought small business out,bankrupted rest.If they didn't co-operate,they were out.Here it was food,household goods tho.Once opposition squashed,claim to lower prices(help poor workin' joe who's unemployed)then go for faulty quality items,GM foods- now they're buying every water source(outlawing rain collecting even)and squashing organics-gov't looks other way(laws benefit BB).Doing global same.What next?pull plug-new age seige.Die or be slave.Controlling all.

Laura

2009-03-31 20:49:53

You can thank the last government for turning the ACCC into a toothless tiger after replacing Alan Fels , and allowing Coles and Woolies into Petrol. I always understood Liberal policy to be about a free market , funny how competition is now almost non-existent , having almost given the big end of town a free kick on the little bloke . Pity the poor farmers , retailers and consumers . Howards battlers yes , he certainly turned it into a battle for many to survive .

justin

2009-03-31 10:25:52

Coles and Woolworths. Just tell me who didn't know that they would crucify small businesses. Not only that Woolworths with a huge Dan Murphy's must know there will be huge blocks of units built in the future in that area. Now there are five story units about to be built in the quiet Normanhurst area. Next will be Thornleigh. What a coincidence!! Don't think so!! Residence don't know until it happens.

Maureen Bassett

2009-03-31 10:08:10

This is a legacy of that great friend of small business, the Howard Govt! They sat on their hands whilst Coles and Woolies swallowed up or drove the competition out of business! So now we pay the price of reduced competition.

mike

2009-03-31 08:34:25

every second month the cpi comes out and food is always the area of the cpi thats inflatting and the farmers arnt getting richer. coles and woolworths sell products cheaper than small business wholesalers so small business carnt compete. you need small business to keep coles and woolworths honest because once small business is gone coles and woolworths will charge what they want. i think its too late for small business to fight back with coles and woolworths owning the majority of the market

joey

Your Opinion

Name:
Email:
Phone:
Address:
Comments:
Remaining:
Kevin Morgan on the future of broadband in Australia. Audio here
Professor George Williams - Election fallout. Audio here
Alan Jones looks at the outcome of the Federal Election. Audio here
FOLLOW US READ ALL BULLETINS

2GB Live Webcams

Newsletter

Signup to the 2GB Newsletter